I applaud the City of Detroit and the State of Michigan for making everyone a winner with the Belle Isle lease agreement. The deal for the state to lease Belle Isle relieves the city of the substantial cost of maintaining the park, and opens the door for significant improvements to this tarnished gem making it an even greater asset to the city. Residents and visitors to Detroit alike should be thrilled with this announcement as everyone stands to benefit. So what lessons can we all take a way from this historic agreement?
Lesson one: Put your good sense ahead of your pride. It sounds easy, but that can be tough to do and takes a fair amount of courage. This decision was not a slam dunk. Not because it didn’t make sense, but because many felt that if the city doesn’t directly manage the park, then it must be a loss for the city. It wouldn’t have been a loss of money, improvements or access, those all improve. None of that made the decision any less difficult. Fortunately all involved had the vision to see that allowing the state to be a partner with the city improves Belle Isle for everyone.
Lesson two: Do what you do best. Belle Isle is a major park that requires a huge continuing investment. Even though it is utilized by many folks outside the city, Detroit bore the full financial burden. In short Detroit was not set up to succeed on this one. The State has more resources, manages large parks, and is actually pretty good at it. The city is far better served by focusing their energy and financial wherewithal on other areas of the city’s operation. They can now put added emphasis on neighborhood parks, public safety or other key areas.
Lesson three: The Stockdale paradox – Confront the brutal truth of the situation, yet at the same time never give up hope. Like so many municipalities in Michigan, the City of Detroit is faced with some very difficult financial circumstances. It serves no one’s purposes, especially your residents, to ignore the reality that we all face. Confront it and utilize all the resources at your disposal to craft a plan that keeps your community moving forward.
My father always told me, “don’t cut off your nose to spite your face”, and it seems appropriate in this circumstance. To have let this opportunity pass would have served no one. We should all learn from the leadership shown here to be open to new ideas, even if that idea stings a little at first. Maybe that idea is in the form of a partnership, or even a hand off. If in the end our residents are better served, then we have done our job. Kudos all around!