Media Throughout Michigan Report on Great Revenue Sharing Heist Study by Michigan Municipal League

League members talk with the media at a press event about revenue sharing at EVIP March 18 in Lansing.

Media from all parts of Michigan have reported on the Michigan Municipal League’s revenue sharing study that showed the state has diverted $6.2 billion from local communities in the last decade. The League released the study last week during our Capital Conference and sent press releases to dozens of media outlets.

Here is a sampling of some of the articles done so far:
- Michgian cities slam state for holding onto $6.2 billion: Detroit News

- Michigan’s $6.2 billion raid on revenue sharing? See how much local communities lost since 2003: statewide

- Wyandotte’s deficit tied to decline in state revenue sharing: The News Heard, the Voice of Downriver

- Revenue sharing could have kept Lincoln Park out of financial crisis, officials say: The News Heard, the Voice of Downriver

- Macomb cities lost more than $100 million due to state cuts: Macomb Daily Tribune

- Michigan Municipal League says Legislature diverted funding; Midland loses $10.9 million: Midland Daily News

- Our View: State turning corner on revenue sharing: Midland Daily News editorial

- Report says Flint lost out on nearly $55 million in revenue sharing in last decade: Flint Journal/

- Six things Flint could have paid for with $55 million in revenue sharing: Flint Journal/

- Michigan Cities contend lost $6.2 billion in lost revenue: Metro Times, Detroit

The League study showed that communities from Marquette to St. Joseph and everywhere in between are among the Michigan cities and villages that lost hundreds of millions of dollars in statutory revenue sharing over the past decade because the governor and Legislature diverted the funds to the state budget.

If the funds had not been diverted by state lawmakers, the fiscal crises facing many local Michigan communities today might not be so severe.

Statutory revenue sharing funds are earmarked by state law for local communities across Michigan to support essential local services including police and fire, water systems, road maintenance, parks and libraries, and more. The funds represent a percentage of sales tax revenues collected at the local levels. Instead, between 2003 and 2013, the governor and Legislature diverted $6.2 billion in statutory revenue sharing from local communities to plug holes in the state budget and to pay for tax cuts for businesses.

Much of this data was also included in the March/April 2014 edition of the Michigan Municipal League Review magazine for an article titled, “The Great Revenue Sharing Heist” by Anthony Minghine, associate executive director and chief operations officer for the Michigan Municipal League. The article is available at

Matt Bach is director of media relations for the Michigan Municipal League. He can be reached at and (734) 669-6317.

Michigan Municipal League’s Partnership for Place Agenda Presented to State Lawmakers

Samantha Harkins discusses the League's Partnership for Place legislative agenda today in Lansing.

Michigan Municipal League staff members met with key state lawmakers today in Lansing about the League’s new proactive legislative agenda, called the Partnership for Place. You can check out the agenda here.

The League is hosting three free webinars for League members about the Partnership for Place agenda 10-11 a.m. Thursday, Aug. 15, and again on Thursday, Aug. 22, and Thursday, Aug. 29. Sign up for any of the one-hour sessions here.

This Partnership for Place legislative agenda is baseed around the belief that thriving communities are key to Michigan’s long-term success and sustainability. The agenda is a commitment of action in partnership between the State and its municipalities to facilitate Michigan’s economic growth and allow for the development of places to provide key services and amenities that contribute to a high quality of life.

The proposed actions called for in the agenda focus on funding, transportation, talent retention, and infrastructure and development. Read the Partnership for Place Agenda.

Matt Bach is director of media relations for the Michigan Municipal League. He can be reached at and (734) 669-6317.

New MSU Report Proposes Solution to Abandoned Private Property Problems

Michigan State University has released a report suggesting ways to help deal with certain blighted, abandoned private property. In the report they suggest performance bonds, or something similar, that could be used to help with the tear down after certain commercial or industrial developments are no longer in use. They provide examples of other industries that use this mechanism as a way for the public to avoid bearing the cost of the end of the life cycle of these private sector developments. League CEO, Dan Gilmartin was quoted in the press release on the topic, saying this type of creative thinking is just what we need to help us solve themany issues that come with blighted abandonded parcels in our communities. The press release can be read here. The report can be found in the link below.

Private Property Abandonment _Full Report_6-25

Michigan Municipal Leaders Seek PPT Fixes, Increases to Revenue Sharing

Durand Mayor Deb Doyle, Linden Mayor David Lossing and East Lansing Mayor Pro Tem Nathan Triplett lay out the League’s legislative priorities during a media roundtable event March 18, 2013 in Lansing. (View the full press release here. View more photos here.)

LANSING, Michigan - The Michigan Municipal League and local leaders held a press conference today calling for action from the state on issues crucial to the future prosperity of Michigan’s cities, villages and urban townships. Topping the list are transportation funding, critical problems with the recently passed personal property tax legisation, and the ongoing pattern of revenue sharing cuts that continue to gut local coffers and make it increasingly difficult to provide the local services that Michigan citizens expect in their communities. Read the press release

Michigan Municipal League President David Lossing, mayor of Linden, led the media roundtable event Monday at the League’s Lansing office. Also speaking were East Lansing Mayor Pro Tem Nathan Triplett, a member of the League board; Durand Mayor Deb Doyle, past president of the League; Samantha Harkins, director of State Affairs, and League CEO Daniel Gilmartin.

About 10 media outlets attended, including reporters from the Associated Press,, Detroit News, Michigan Public Radio, TV 6 and TV 10; MIRS and Gongwer news services; and Lansing City Pulse. In addition, the Lansing State Journal wrote an editorial related to this issue, and WKAR public radio show, Current State with Mark Bashore, interviewed Lossing and Gilmartin Monday morning. You can listen to that here.

“While the problems facing Michigan’s communities is the result of many factors, it is still a fact that the state government, legislatures and governors alike, have cut revenue sharing for local municipalities by more than $4.2 billion over the past dozen years,” Lossing stated in a press release distributed at the event. “It is a fact that the state government has taken those funds and used them to solve problems in the state budget or to pay for state programs and policies. And it is a fact that those cuts have contributed to thousands of local police officers and firefighters losing their jobs, reductions in road and bridge repairs, massive cuts to local parks and libraries, and much more. Michigan cities have been largely pushed aside by our state government for far too long, and anything short of an increase in statutory revenue sharing is not good enough.”

Gov. Rick Snyder has proposed no funding increases for statutory revenue sharing in his 2014 state budget, despite the massive cuts made to revenue sharing funding over the past decade.

In addition, legislation passed in December – on the final day of the last state Legislature session – would cut another stable source of local funding for local communities — the business personal property tax (PPT). This legislation would cut local community funding up to 20 percent in many communities, assuming Michigan voters approve a ballot question authorizing the PPT law to take effect. The Legislature still has not voted to put the PPT law on the August 2014 statewide primary ballot.

Daniel Gilmartin, CEO and executive director of the Michigan Municipal League, said the PPT legislation passed in December created “several outstanding issues” that must be resolved.

“We delivered a letter to the Lieutenant Governor outlining the issues in the PPT bills that must be resolved, and we were told they would be resolved,” Gilmartin said. “It is essential that those issues be fixed, and anything short of that is not good enough. If they are not resolved, replacement funding to local communities would be threatened to the point of potentially causing irreparable and permanent fiscal damage to literally dozens or hundreds of Michigan cities.”

Samantha Harkins, director of state affairs for the League, said Michigan cities are also concerned about the transportation funding proposals being considered by the Governor and Legislature. While the League supports a substantial increase in investments for transportation infrastructure and transit, any proposal that fails to increase funding to specifically address local infrastructure needs will not be good enough.

“Anyone who travels our local roads and state highways knows that Michigan’s transportation system and infrastructure are in deplorable shape and in desperate need of a major reinvestment,” said East Lansing Mayor Pro Tem Nathan Triplett. “The state must provide a level of funding that adequately addresses local transportation system needs. Inaction is not an option.”

Other officials attending the event were Meridian Township officials Julie Brixie, and Milton Scales; East Lansing Councilmember Kathy Boyle, Caro Councilmember Joseph Greene; Gladwin Mayor Thomas Winarski; Grand Blanc Mayor Susan Soderstrom; Grand Haven Councilmember Robert Monetza; Huntington Woods Mayor Ron Gillham; Ithaca Councilmember L.D. Hollenbeck;  and Quincy Village Manager Eric Zuzga.

Matt Bach is director of media relations for the Michigan Municipal League. He can be reached at and (734) 669-6317.

Media from about 10 different outlets attend the Michigan Municipal League’s media roundtable event Monday in Lansing. (View the full press release here. View more photos here.)

Personal Property Tax Changes Concerns Many Michigan Municipal Officials

Planned changes to the state’s personal property tax have many Michigan Municipal League member communities concerned, as reflected in recent articles posted this week. out of Jackson and the Observer & Eccentric out of Northville each posted stories recently outlining community leader concerns over the financial impact from proposed changes to Michigan’s personal property tax.

Here is part of what Albion City Manager Dan Bishop was quoted as saying on “Starting next year the personal property tax law will change so that businesses with less than $40,000 in assets will not pay the tax by fiscal year 2014. The tax will be phased out in anywhere from five to seven years. It’s a target that keeps moving.”

Under the headline “State lawmakers get earful from Northville, Plymouth leaders on elimination of personal property tax” here is a portion of the O&E article:

“Northville faces an estimated 2014 loss of $59,113 while Plymouth stands to lose $38,580 in PPT revenue, officials said. Those figures are net of state replacement money (which does not apply in Northville because of the PPT’s small effect on the overall tax base) and money from local assessments, subject to local votes, designed to replace PPT money that goes toward public safety purposes. We are really concerned when we see these numbers — you know in our situation 97 percent of the loss is going to be lost to the city under the current setup,” Northville Mayor Chris Johnson told State Rep. Kurt Heise, R-Plymouth Township, and state Sens. Patrick Colbeck, R-Canton Township, and Mike Kowall, R-White Lake Township, at the meeting. Northville has 429 parcels out of 471 being impacted by the change, which is about 91 percent of the businesses. This is a net loss of 97 percent of the revenue the tax generates.”

League staff is well aware of the concerns our members have over these proposed changes and continue to work with lawmakers on the issues. Stay tuned to this Inside 208 blog by Michigan Municipal League staff for regular updates on this topic.

To help calculate a the impact of the new personal property tax reform on our communities, the Michigan Department of Treasury has put together a spreadsheet that you can find here: PPT Plan Local Unit Worksheet 12 17 12.xls (40.50 kb).

For further reading check out recent Lansing State Journal and Detroit Free Press editorials about the uncertain future of municipal finances.

Matt Bach is director of media relations for the Michigan Municipal League. He can be reached at

Municipal Officials Learn About Placemaking, Legislative Issues at Seminar

(View photos from the event here).

Municipal managers from throughout Michigan were in Rochester this week (Jan. 29-Feb. 1, 2013) for the 2013 Michigan Local Government Management Association (MLGMA) Winter Institute.

The theme of this year’s event was communication and city, village, county and township officials attended a variety of sessions on leadership, placemaking strategies, the latest political issues in Lansing, innovation, social media, labor law, the Freedom of Information Act, emergency management, motivating staff and much more. Michigan Municipal League’s Samantha Harkins gave the officials an update on the personal property tax issues and the League’s Summer Minnick and Arnold Weinfeld led a session about the latest legislation impacting municipalities.

Other keynote speakers included Rochester Mayor Pro Tem Jeffrey Cuthbertson, Dennis Mannion, president and CEO of the Palace of Auburn Hills & Detroit Pistons, Tom Daldin and Jim Edleman, creators of Under the Radar Michigan on PBS television, Brian Glowiak, director of civic relations and community engagement for Chrysler and Vice President of The Chrysler Foundation; Greg Kampe, head basketball coach at Oakland University; and Tim Skubick, senior capitol correspondent and host of Off the Record. For more about MLGMA go to MLGMA is an affiliate organization of the Michigan Municipal League. For more about the League and what we do go to

Matt Bach is director of media relations for the Michigan Municipal League. He can be reached at (734) 669-6317 and

Samantha Harkins talks about the personal property tax issue during the 2013 MLGMA Winter Institute in Rochester. For more photos from the event go here.

It’s Time to Replace the Plywood with Pavement, says League President on State of State Speech

Plywood under a bridge going over a Michigan expressway. Image from

This statement is from Linden Mayor David Lossing, president of the Michigan Municipal League Board of Trustees. Lossing is commenting on tonight’s State of the State address by Gov. Rick Snyder, who called for new investment in Michigan’s crumbling transportation system.

“Michigan’s transportation infrastructure is in critical condition, threatening thousands of jobs, the state’s economy, our cities, and public safety. Michigan roads consistently rank among the nation’s worst. Our local roads and bridges are in desperate need of funding for essential maintenance. We need transit system and infrastructure improvements that will help create the types of communities attractive to a skilled workforce and those industries that are thriving in the 21st century economy. We can cut all the taxes we want, but if we can’t move goods from point A to point B, it won’t do us any good. Bottom line: it’s time to replace the plywood patches on too many Michigan highway bridges with pavement. It’s time to fix our roads and rebuild our infrastructure so Michigan is again attractive to employers and a talented workforce.”

Posted by Matt Bach, director of media relations for the Michigan Municipal League, 734-669-6317 and

Michigan Municipal League Training Weeks Kick Off with FOIA, OMA Session

William Mathewson talks to League members about the Open Meetings Act at an education session Wednesday in Ann Arbor. View more photos here.

ANN ARBOR, Michigan – The first of a series of new training weeks kicked off today with sessions on the state’s Freedom of Information Act, Open Meetings Act and Parliamentary Procedure. The training week concept is a new service the League is providing to bring our vast array of education services to various parts of the state. League members and non-members can register for a whole week of trainings or pick and choose the topics that interest them.

About 20 local officials primarily from southeast Michigan attended the first training week education session today at the League headquarters in Ann Arbor. We had officials attending the training from numerous communities, including Britton, Southfield, Ann Arbor, Highland Park, Ecorse, Ferndale, Galdwin, Orchard Lake Village, Southgate, Suttons Bay, Troy, Farmington and Saline.

The training week sessions will continue in Ann Arbor Thursday and Friday. Go here for details. Today’s sessions on the Open Meetings Act (OMA) and Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) were led by William Mathewson, general counsel for the League. A training about parliamentary procedure is taking place later this evening and will be led by Professioinal Parliamentarian Coco Siewert. The League will also host a free meet-up gathering for League members from 4-7 p.m. Thursday, Jan. 17, at our Ann Arbor office, 1675 Green Road, following the Thursday afternoon education session.

Future training weeks are planned in Frankenmuth, Feb. 14-15; Kalamazoo, March 13-15; Lansing, April 24-26; Mackinaw City, May 15-17 and Muskegon, June 5-7. Topics planned at these future sessions include finance for the non-finance municipal official, service consolidation and shared services, and engaging your citizen change makers. You can register for the sessions here.

View additional photos from the event here in this set on flickr.

Matt Bach is director of media relations for the Michigan Municipal League. He can be reached at (734) 669-6317 and

Michigan Municipal Leaders Participate in Live Chat About PPT, Emergency Management, Other Issues

More than 100 municipal leaders attended a live chat hosted by the Michigan Municipal League Tuesday about bills approved in the lame duck session of the Michigan Legislature in recent weeks.

During the live chat, led by the League’s Anthony Minghine and Samantha Harkins, Minghine started out explaining that the purpose of the call was to inform League members about the action taken in Lansing and that the League will have future education materials and sessions for members that will delve more deeply into the bills and potential issues and concerns members may have about them. Go here to listen to a recording of the chat. Go here for a spreadsheet communities can use to calculate the impact of the PPT plan.

The main issue discussed Tuesday was the repeal of the business personal property tax (view a detailed blog post about the package of PPT bills approved by the Legislature). The PPT is a tax on manufacturing equipment that is collected locally. It’s a huge amount of revenue for some cities with a large industrial base, such as River Rouge, where industrial property comprises 57% of the city’s taxable value; Auburn Hills, where 22% of the city’s taxable value comes from the personal property tax; Romeo where 37.4% of the city’s taxable value comes from the PPT; and Detroit, where 16.6% of the city’s taxable value comes from PPT, according to 2010 figures compiled by the League.

Other legislative issues reviewed on the call were the emergency managment bill, and regional transit authority bills. A flurry of bills went before the Legislature during the lame duck session and many have a direct and indirect impact on Michigan communities. Here are links to League blog posts about bills related to the following issues:

- Medical Marijuana
- Changes to the recall law
- Pawn shop local pre-emption
- Village elections moved to November
- Brownfield redevelopment financing amendments
- Indemnification bill for contractors
- Expanded strategic water quality initiatives loan program

Matt Bach is director of media relations for the Michigan Municipal League. He can be reached at 734-669-6317 and

PPT Moves Forward in Michigan House, Call Your Republican Representatives Today

LANSING, Michigan – Ignoring pleas from the Michigan Municipal League and other organizations to slow down, the House Tax Policy Committee today pressed forward during this lame duck session to repeal the personal property tax. And now the League needs help from our members and the general public as the bills move to the full House.

Despite hearing numerous unanswered questions and concerns, the Tax Policy Committee voted along party lines (with Republicans supporting) to move the bills to the full House floor. The House could vote on the package as soon as today, but tomorrow is most likely.

These bills do not provide the revenue replacement guarantees the League has requested and could be yet another financial blow to Michigan communities already strapped with declining property tax revenue and loss of revenue sharing dollars.

The League needs our members and the public to contact their Republican representatives today and tell them they need to vote against this package of bills because they will hurt the local communities they were elected to represent. Below are some talking points you can follow and a list of the Republican members of the House and their contact information. PLEASE contact them TODAY. It’s essential they hear you!

Talking points:

- We are not opposed to the repeal of The PPT. We are opposed to rushing through this process when there are numerous questions that have not been addressed.

- Guaranteed replacement revenue is an absolute requirement. The cut or elimination of the PPT must not take effect if the ballot proposal to dedicate the use tax to replacement revenues is not approved by Michigan voters. The two must be tie-barred. If the use tax question is not approved by Michigan voters, the cut to PPT must not take effect.

- What is the impact of the extremely complicated formulas for calculating the Essential Services Assessment (ESA) and the reallocation of the use tax? Without an opportunity to fully vet the formulas against community data, we can’t be sure of their impact on our communities.

- Is there an opportunity for a local referendum to block the ESA?

- Why create a new level of government with its added cost and bureaucracy that appears to have broad power with little to no state oversight? This authority could create new conditions on funding that is vital for local operations.

- This 80% reimbursement is not acceptable; we need to get closer to 100% replacement funding.

- There were last minute amendments to the package of bills approved and it is not clear what those amendments do. One has to do with the ESA first being applied to retiree debt. We don’t know the impact of the amendments added in committee today.

- The ESA should be allowed for all public safety, not just police, fire, and ambulance. It must include all public safety functions, including 9-1-1 authorities, special public safety millages, public health, etc. These are not viewed or typically funded separately at the local level.

- Cutting our revenue by varying amounts across the state without providing relief from our obligations will force locals to make up the revenue elsewhere.

- This combined with ESA shifts the taxing burden from the state to the locally elected body. Assessing a new tax or increasing an existing tax is as unpopular locally as it is on the state level.

- How will Treasury determine “total restricted qualified loss”?

- Will the ESA pass scrutiny under legal review?

List of Republican state representatives:






John J. Walsh

(517) 373-3920


Kurt Heise

(517) 373-3816


Pat Somerville

(517) 373-0855


Anthony G. Forlini

(517) 373-0113


Jeff Farrington

(517) 373-7768


Andrea LaFontaine

(517) 373-8931


Ken Goike

(517) 373-0820


Peter J. Lund

(517) 373-0843


Hugh D. Crawford

(517) 373-0827


Charles Moss

(517) 373-8670


Martin Knollenberg

(517) 373-1783


Gail Haines

(517) 373-0615


Eileen Kowall

(517) 373-2616


Tom McMillin

(517) 373-1773


Bradford C. Jacobsen

(517) 373-1798


Cynthia S. Denby

(517) 373-8835


Joseph Graves

(517) 373-1780


Mark Ouimet

(517) 373-0828


Rick Olson

(517) 373-1792


Dale W. Zorn

(517) 373-2617


Nancy E. Jenkins

(517) 373-1706


Kenneth Kurtz

(517) 373-1794


Matthew J. Lori

(517) 373-0832


Margaret E. O’Brien

(517) 373-1774


Jase Bolger

(517) 373-1787


Earl Poleski

(517) 373-1795


Michael Shirkey

(517) 373-1775


William Rogers

(517) 373-1784


Rick Outman

(517) 373-0834


Deb Lynn Shaughnessy

(517) 373-0853


Ken Yonker

(517) 373-0840


Peter MacGregor

(517) 373-0218


David Agema

(517) 373-8900


Roy Schmidt

(517) 373-0822


Thomas B. Hooker

(517) 373-2277


Sharon Tyler

(517) 373-1796


Al Pscholka

(517) 373-1403


Aric Nesbitt

(517) 373-0839


Judson S. Gilbert II

(517) 373-1790


Kevin Daley

(517) 373-1800


Paul Muxlow

(517) 373-0835


Kurt Damrow

(517) 373-0476


Ben Glardon

(517) 373-0841


Lisa Posthumus Lyons

(517) 373-0846


Mike Callton

(517) 373-0842


Robert J. Genetski II

(517) 373-0836


Amanda Price

(517) 373-0838


Joseph Haveman

(517) 373-0830


Holly Hughes

(517) 373-3436


Paul E. Opsommer

(517) 373-1778


Kenneth B. Horn

(517) 373-0837


Joel Johnson

(517) 373-8962


Jim Stamas

(517) 373-1791


Kevin Cotter

(517) 373-1789


Jon Bumstead

(517) 373-7317


Ray A. Franz

(517) 373-0825


Phil Potvin

(517) 373-1747


Bruce R. Rendon

(517) 373-3817


Wayne A. Schmidt

(517) 373-1766


Greg MacMaster

(517) 373-0829


Peter Pettalia

(517) 373-0833


Frank Foster

(517) 373-2629


Ed McBroom

(517) 373-0156


Matt Huuki

(517) 373-0850


Anthony Minghine and Samantha Harkins of the Michigan Municipal League testify about the personal property tax Wednesday in Lansing.